geoviki: (peeps)
geoviki ([personal profile] geoviki) wrote2005-05-05 08:11 am

Gratuitous overuse of the frog analogy

A recent book review in our newspaper read:

Wallace Stegner writes ... that the difficulty with explicit sex in novels is that it invariably usurps all else that the author is attempting to accomplish:

"The trouble with excessive sexuality, in novels or in life, is that it is so compellingly interesting and attention-holding that it makes everything else seem tame or dull; it crowds off the page whole areas of human experience and human feeling that belong there but can't maintain their foothold."

Such is the case in Sue Miller's newest novel, Lost in the Forest. Although Miller's exploration of grief and self-discovery is both compelling and insightful, the sexual trysts of 16-year-old Daisy are so unforgivingly explicit that Miller's attempts to uncover the depth of who Daisy is are muddled by a nipple here and an arched back there....


I thought this over and decided that somewhere, I had crossed over to where this wasn't true for me. I've noticed that after reading fan fiction for nearly two years, I no longer find excessive sexuality all that distracting. It's like the classic analogy of the frog in slowly heating water: little by little, I no longer notice the erosion of my ability to be shocked, tittilated, or even surprised by graphic writing. I have become comfortably numb.

How about you?

Aside: Does anyone have an mp3 of Led Zeppelin's Stairway to Heaven that I can, er, borrow? Got it. Thanks, Paula!

[identity profile] scoradh.livejournal.com 2005-05-13 09:43 pm (UTC)(link)
I have been thinking about this for days.

I have become comfortably numb.


Yes, I have. I came into the fandom through reading a yahoo article describing, of all things, a Snarry exerpt. While the whole idea of fanfic -- clearly! -- intrigued me, I swore never to read above a PG rating.

Yeah, that lasted all of a week.

It was only by getting a journal that I found the real hardcore stuff and yes, it shocked me initially, particularly [livejournal.com profile] amanuensis1's stuff. I did like it, though, despite a distaste for BDSM.

However, the point is that my RL friend was surfing my journal and came across an explicit Ginny/Harry/Draco threesome -- I do believe it was by [livejournal.com profile] florahart. She was utterly shocked. I had to pretend I didn't know it was there, to save face...:)

As for myself, I find porn gets oh so very generic. As [livejournal.com profile] minnow_53 said, the minute you can interchange Adam and Steve for the characters' names it's gone. I find many novellas descend into an almost-squalid repetition of sex this, suck that, bugger that one. I do find it boring and I do think the author has to be supremely talented to carry it off. *coughnotlookingatanyoneinparticularcough*

Mmm, anyway. I see ADSoT is up! *squees in undignified manner* Expect one of my embarrassing reviews in the near future. :)