Hi -- I'm here via The Daily Snitch. And I agree with everyone who's already stated that leaving concrit on gift fics is inappropriate. I also think it's in poor taste.

I stumbled onto someone's LJ the other day and discovered that this person is publicly posting negative (IMHO) reviews of all the smutmas stories. It made me sick to my stomach. The idea of someone taking another person's "gift" and smashing it to bits in public (and without regard for the gifter or giftee -- particularly as the anon author can't respond at this time) is revolting to me.